Canada, the King, and the Question We Keep Dodging

I have no issue with King Charles. I have no objection to his throne speech in Canada. What I do question, however, is what this moment says about how we see ourselves — and how we continue to define Canada not by what it is, but by what it is not. When Prime Minister Justin Trudeau was asked some years ago what the Canadian identity is, his response was: “We are not Americans.” That answer stuck with me — not because it was offensive, but because it was empty. Why are we so comfortable defining our national identity in contrast to others, instead of taking the time to articulate who we are? Now, in 2025, as King Charles prepares to deliver the throne speech in Canada — a role traditionally reserved for the Governor General — I feel a similar discomfort. Not because of tradition, but because of the subtext. Once again, we seem to be reaching for external validation, relying on monarchy to remind the world (and perhaps ourselves) that we are not the 51st state. But I can’t help but w...